New Workshop: Photographing Group Portraits!

News & Insight

Nikon D610: The DSLR The D600 Should Have Been?

By Matthew Saville on October 8th 2013

Nikon has announced the D610, an amateur / prosumer level full-frame DSLR body for $1,999.  Coming out barely a year after the Nikon D600 and with almost identical features, the question is this: shouldn’t Nikon simply have dubbed it the “D600s” instead?  Probably.  Actually, most of the time a Nikon “S” camera update has even more improvements than this.  Regardless, here are the specs of the D610, with commentary:

Nikon D610 Specifications

  • 24 megapixel full-frame CMOS sensor
    The same awe-inspiring image quality that we described in our complete D600 field review, which you can find HERE:  Incredible dynamic range, mostly on-par with the Nikon D800‘s dynamic range in fact, and great overall image quality.
  • ISO 100-6400 native, ISO 50-25600 with “HI” and “LO” options
    Again the same as the D600, and once again there’s nothing wrong with that!  If there is any glimmer of hope, it is important to note that often times even the same sensor can yield slightly better final images in a camera “update”.  Any time Nikon makes an “S” version of a camera, ISO performance gets almost a stop better.  No promises so far, but just something to keep in mind.  Most likely there is no difference, otherwsie Nikon would have touted it.
  • 39 point autofocus
    Again the same as the D600, however this is actually unfortunate because personally I have found Nikon’s 39 point AF to be just slightly less amazing than the flagship 51 point AF in the likes of the Nikon D800, D700, and of course the Nikon D4.  But then again, what do you expect in a consumer-oriented DSLR?
  • A “completely new” shutter assembly, capable of 6 FPS instead of the D600’s 5.5 FPS and a better silent mode
    Of course a 0.5 FPS improvement isn’t even the real reason Nikon did away with the D600’s old shutter assembly, nor is a better silent mode.  (Although Nikon’s previous “silent mode” was kind of a joke, so this is quite welcome…)
    No, anyone who considered buying a D600 would tell you that there were widespread issues with dirty sensors due to shutter oil finding its way onto the sensor and attracting lots of dust.  In fact according to some, Nikon’s entire reason for releasing the D610 is this one single issue….ending the bad reputation that the D600 received because of the sensor oil issue.
    There were also reports of the Nikon D600 having other, more serious shutter or exposure issues, however in either case the response from Nikon has always been, “if there is anything wrong, send it in and we will fix it!”  (More on this crucial issue in just a minute)
    …But Wait!  Still 1/4000th sec max shutter speed, and 1/200th max sync speed
    Okay so, “completely new” was a bit of a stretch for the D610’s shutter assembly.  Some photographers had hoped that Nikon would up the ante and stick the D800’s shutter in the D600, giving it 1/8000th sec max speed and 1/250th sec max flash sync.
  • Better Auto White Balance
    While this might be useful to many amateurs and hobbyists or even a few select professionals who choose to use the D610 in a few select conditions in which auto white balance is useful, it isn’t a feature worth more than a few dollars in our opinion.
  • Weather sealing to match that of the D800
    While ambiguous, the wording of the specification is indeed different from that of the D600’s original announcement.  It is possible that the D610 has slightly better weather sealing.
  • Same body layout, controls, features, and customizations all-around VS the D600
    We won’t know for sure just how deep the identical-ness goes until we actually get one in our hands, however aside from the shutter, WB and possible weather sealing improvements, it seems that the D610 is going to be identical to the D600.
    This is good because the D600 already had fantastic features and decent control functionality, however I will definitely be very, very sad if the D610 does not turn out to have two more obscure features that even the new DX sensor D7100 has:  True oldschool “bulb” shutter mode, (click-open, click-shut style instead of “hold the shutter down for the entire exposure” style) …and 1-click 100% zooming during image playback with the customization of the “OK” button.

 

nikon-d610-top nikon-d610-back nikon-d610-front-1 nikon-d610-front-2

Pre-Ordering

The Nikon D610 will be available later this month, and you can pre-order it at the following links:

B&H – Nikon D610 – Body Only – $1999

B&H – Nikon D610 – Kit with 24-85mm lens – $2599

B&H – Nikon D610 – Kit with 28-300mm lens – $3049

B&H – Nikon D610 – Kit with 24-85mm & 70-300mm lens – $3249

Amazon – Nikon D610 (body only and kits available)

Is the D610 worth buying compared to the D600?

Mainly in my opinion, it all comes down timing, (how soon you need a camera) …and what you need from your camera.  The differences between the two cameras are minor, and the biggest issues with the D600 seem to be one that Nikon is willing to fix for free.

Therefore, unless there is an actual issue with the D600’s overall shutter reliability, the D600 seems to still be an absolute great buy, if you can pick one up for cheap and still get access to the warranty.  (And learn to clean your sensor, and clean it regularly… ;-)

Of course keep in mind that brand new D600’s are probably going to disappear pretty quick, so soon this whole thing will be a moot point.  The bottom line is that both of these cameras are totally worth $2000 for their overall image quality alone, and within a few months the D610 will be the only camera available new.

In other words, if you already own a D600 you probably won’t need to upgrade, but if you haven’t bought one yet then it’s a toss-up for the time being.  Maybe if there are a few subtle  software-based differences the D610 could be of greater value to more discerning photographers?  Or of course, if the D610’s shutter isn’t susceptible to excessive amounts of dust, that would be valuable to many as well.

Either way, we’ll have a brief review online soon!

Take care,
=Matthew Saville=

Matthew Saville is a full-time wedding photographer at Lin & Jirsa Photography, and a senior editor & writer at SLR Lounge.

Follow his personal wilderness adventures: Astro-Landscapes.com

See some of his latest wedding photography featured on: LinandJirsa.com

6 Comments

Please or register to post a comment.

  1. Leo g

    Returned my D600 today for the third time. After shutter was replaced the second time, spots started to return. Spoke to nikon today and they said they are going to replace D600 with D610. Packed up camera and sent it on its way. Hope this solves problem at last. Still think camera is worth all the trouble.

    | |
  2. Leo G

    Bought D600 when first came out. Great camera, but, spots in upper left like everyone else. Sent it back for cleaning. Nikon cleaned and also replaced shutter. Spots have returned, but am not sending it in again. This is usually only a problem with blank spaces like blue sky, and only if you stop lens down. I can live with these problems and work around them. I do think nikon knows, and knew about this problem, but wouldn’t admit it. The d610 is probably a great camera, but for anyone with a D600 to buy one would be foolish. I have too much invested in Nikon glass to switch brands, as I suppose many others have also. Use your 600, enjoy your pictures. As many people have said, good lenses will last a lifetime, digital camera bodies come and go. There’s a better body coming along sooner or later.

    | |
    • Paul

      Ooooooooh I did send my D600 once more to Nikon and guess what? Received a brand new D610 back without any charge.

      I see a much better camera – as written here, the D600 seems to have an exposure problem!!! also, the D610 yields perfect images now.

      | |
    • Leo g

      Bought a 105 macro lens, used aperatures in the 22-32 range and saw many spots. Thankfully nikon made their offer to replace shutters in cameras whether under warranty or not. Sent camera back again, and so far no spots. Time will tell. Only thing I can not get a clear answer on, is what shutter did they replace old one with. Do I have an old 600 shutter, a better old 600 shutter, a 610 shutter, or something else.

      | |
  3. Tom

    Well it IS $100.00 cheaper than the D600, but I suppose that’s going to change very quickly. My disappointment is the same clustered AF points, I was waiting to see if they’d change this. Sadly, no.

    | |
  4. ken weil

    I find everything about the 610 great except WTF having it a 4000/sec instead of 8000. Did Nikon do that just to piss people off? People actually do go 8000. Nikon is playing games.

    | |
[i]
[i]