Photographing the Milky Way

Your content will be up shortly. Please allow up to 5 seconds
Insights & Thoughts

Photography Actions and Presets Are The Devil! Or Are They? The Benefits of Using Them In Your Workflow

By Max Bridge on February 14th 2015

You occasionally see comments within the photographic community similar to the title of this article, “Actions and Presets are the Devil!” Well, perhaps not the devil, but you may have heard it said that they’re for amateurs or are the bane of creativity and that only those that don’t know what they’re doing use them. I disagree.

Actions and Presets can be bad if used in the wrong way (I’ll refer to them as AP’s from now on); for instance, as a crutch to mask a person’s lack of editing ability. The result of which can only be to hamper your progression and, in turn, creativity.  I would always advise someone to take the time to learn a program before either buying or creating actions. That way you know what everything does, why it’s being used and most importantly, what you want to tweak. 

[REWIND: POST PROCESSING: ADOBE LIGHTROOM PRESETS OR PHOTOSHOP ACTIONS?]

lightroom-presets-tutorial-101

Why I Use Actions and Presets

I do hours and hours of editing each week. That could be anything from spending hours on one photo in Photoshop to a matter of minutes per photo in Lightroom. AP’s are a huge part of my workflow. I cannot imagine finishing a family photo shoot, having 400-600 images, and going through all the sliders in Lightroom for every image. That sounds like madness to me!

Benefits to using AP’s

Speed – This is an obvious one, but worth mentioning. A well-crafted set of AP’s can really help you fly through your initial edit. Remember, you can always return to images at a later stage to apply those final little touches.

[RELATED: Check out our favorite Lightroom Recipes here]

Memory – This is a big one for me. My memory is appalling! Whenever I used to come across a good Lightroom or Photoshop technique, I’d create an Action or Preset. I still do. Some techniques take lots of steps and without actions, honestly, I would forget.

Encouraging Creativity – That’s right. I genuinely believe that if you have an excellent set of AP’s, it will actually encourage creativity. I find they allow me to flow a little better when I edit, less thinking about the steps and more about the final look.   

For me, those are the three main benefits and really they cannot be underestimated. I guarantee that if you went to any professional retoucher, they would tell you that they use AP’s to some extent. Why not? I have actions for everything; frequency separation, check layers, removing CA, dodging and burning, whitening teeth, enhancing eyes…I could go on and on. Here’s a screen grab of my PS set up. I have the actions in button mode and as you can see there are quite a few.

PS - small

Another minor, but still useful benefit is organization. If you’re anything like me, naming layers can seem a bit of a chore. My PS actions are named and even colour coded which really helps. Sometimes, I manually create layers and am still a little lazy, but having the majority named makes a big difference. Take a look at the image below. Those are all the layers I used on the image above of a friend of mine. Almost all of those layers were created, named and grouped using Actions.   

Layers

Wow, So I Can Just Use Actions and Presets As a Shortcut For Everything…

NO! Certainly there are lots of places where AP’s can be used, but some tasks just take time, there is no way around it. For example, yes I use an action to set up my frequency separation layers. However, the actual process of removing blemishes and smoothing the transitions between shadows and highlights takes time. I think this is another place where AP’s get a bad name. Some systems claim to do everything and unfortunately, that just can’t work. Those systems will hamper creativity, act as a crutch and ultimately ruin your images. It all comes back to knowing your programs prior to creating or purchasing AP’s.

Now we know that AP’s can be good let me also say that when you purchase systems they are by no means created equally. There are so many opportunities for us as photographers to throw our money down the drain and unfortunately, buying a poorly designed Preset or Action system is one of them.

I’ve accumulated and created all of my PS actions myself and if you go down this route, I cannot stress enough how important it is for you to firstly, record the actions correctly and secondly, have a logical system. If you ignore those two steps, then your actions will probably slow you down. There’s a great video from the guys over at Phlearn which takes you through the proper way to create actions.

I never recommend something I have not tried hence I cannot recommend any PS action systems for you to purchase. If you guys know of any great ones leave a comment below. I can however recommend a great system for Lightroom. I’ve used it for quite some time now, before writing on here, and must say it’s great. Obviously, I am talking about the SLR Lounge Preset system. I’m not going to go into detail about the system as you can find plenty of info and reviews either on here or elsewhere online. I will say that it is very well designed and does a great job at encouraging creativity. And everything is named properly! I can’t stand stupid names for Presets. 

before

after

About the Guest Contributor

Max Bridge began his career within the film industry, starting as a Runner and ending as a 2nd AC (assistant cameraman). Max worked on everything from a banned horror film to multi-million pound commercials crewed by top industry professionals. After suffering a back injury, he left the film industry and is now using his knowledge to pursue a career within photography.

 You can find Max on Twitter, Facebook, Pinterest and his website.

About

Max began his career within the film industry. He’s worked on everything from a banned horror film to multi-million-pound commercials crewed by top industry professionals. After suffering a back injury, Max left the film industry and is now using his knowledge to pursue a career within photography.

Website: SquareMountain 
Instagram: Follow Author

Q&A Discussions

Please or register to post a comment.

  1. J. Dennis Thomas

    I can’t stand canned presets at all. I have photoshop actions for some things, but never to do with with color/exposure/contrast.

    I treat every single one of my images differently if they’re similar in exposure and tone I might click “Previous” in LR5, but I almost always tweak something.

    | |
  2. Ed Rhodes

    “Bobby Bouche, Actions/Presets are the Devil!”

    “Mama says that photographers are so ornery b/c they gots all those lenses and no lens brush.”

    “Bobby, my momma told me not to get a tattoo of Ansel Adams on my ass, but what mama don’t know won’t hurt her.”

    | |
    • Max Bridge

      Ed, that is exactly what I was thinking about when I wrote the title of this article!

      For anyone that does not know we are referring to “The Waterboy”, one of Adam Sandler’s best films.

      | |
  3. Ralph Hightower

    I saw the demo video of SLR Lounge presets and it looks great. But for a “film” look, I’ll use film. I try to do minimal post processing; with film and digital, I’ve noticed problems with C-41 B&W films, Kodak BW400CN and Ilford XP2, not turning out in scans as traditional B&W, so I have to make those adjustments.

    | |
  4. norman tesch

    its not that the presets are bad until…everyone uses the same one for every photo and it turns into a fad. i myself am so sick of seeing that washed out, over exposed look

    | |
    • Max Bridge

      Hello Norman. Thank you for sharing your thoughts. On many levels I totally agree with you, it is definitely one of the negatives people associate with Presets.

      In terms of the washed out look you are referring to, personally , I still like it. I try not to overuse the effect however if I fell an image calls for it I have no hesitation in using it. I am exactly like you though, there are certain effects and looks that I cannot stand. All personal preference I suppose.

      | |
    • jozef povazan

      I had couple wedding shows this year and one of the reasons why our brides were booking us on the spot was that none of our images was overexposed shot with washed out effect shot at f1.4… I agree some images can look quite aesthetic in backlighted late afternoon light shot wide open, but some people are simply nuts to use it all day long even for dramatic scenery shots which could look so amazing without being ruined buy wrong LR preset abuse :) BTW I like your preset system when used carefully and well planned :)

      | |
  5. Murray Severn

    I can agree with you on this. I would love to have the SLR LR presets, but I’m still learning the program at the moment and my volume of photography doesn’t need it yet.
    I did a course for something else and was given an action file for PS to do a task. For a while I was scratching my head as to what the action was actually doing to get the end result, and it wasn’t until I needed to create my own action that I realized how to look at all the steps that made up that action.

    | |
    • Brandon Dewey

      One thing I like about the way the SRL Lounge Pre-set is set up it really allows me to create my own unique presets. Using LR pre-sets in my work flow really speed up my editing time. My pre set it will normally get me in the ball park of where I what the final image to be and the make fine to adjustment to that image to create the final image.

      | |
    • Max Bridge

      Hey Murray. Thanks for your comment. I think that regardless of whether the volume of editing you do requires presets or not, it is very sensible to learn the programs a little more first. Once you have Prestes and Actions will be a fantastic addition for you.

      In terms of Photoshop actions make sure you watch the Phlearn video above on how to create them correctly. I wish I’d seen that video a long time ago. I built all of mine the wrong way and had to re-do them all!

      Brandon – I completely agree with you! Glad you like the Preset system as well.

      | |
[i]
[i]