Holiday Sale! Secret Bundle + 30% Off

Your content will be up shortly. Please allow up to 5 seconds
Ramblings About Retouching | Is “I’ll Fix It In Post” Still a Dirty Phrase? Post Production Tips

Ramblings About Retouching | Is “I’ll Fix It In Post” Still a Dirty Phrase?

By Max Bridge on September 1st 2016

Good retouching is vital to the creation of high-quality images and always has been. In the days of the darkroom, photographers spent hours, as they do today, perfecting their images. Somewhere along the way, people began to look at post production as a bad thing: “If you can’t get it right in camera, then you’re not a good photographer.”

There may be some truth in that phrase, but it should not be a blanket statement which prohibits the use of high quality, extensive retouching. Or should it? In this article I’ll explore this topic and give my thoughts on when heavy retouching is appropriate and when (maybe) it’s not.

Why Has Retouching Got A Bad Name?

As the world has become more aware of the possibilities retouching allows, so too has the world found a distaste for it. I don’t believe it’s a distaste for retouching itself but more so a realization that quite often their eyes have been deceived. It’s as though people feel they are being lied to, at least that’s what they think, and they don’t like it.

[REWIND: GUIDE TO TETHERED SHOOTING USING CAPTURE ONE PRO]

Whether it be a celebrity on the cover of a magazine edited beyond recognition, a model whose already slim body has been manipulated further, or some other kind of Photoshop atrocity, People have had enough of the “fake”. I actually think a lot of this is rooted in a new fashion / trend. The #nofilter generation who take an hour to take their #nofilter photo. However, I also think that much of retouching’s bad reputation has come from a few, large-scale, mainstream media mistakes, which have brought to light the editing that many images go through. These mistakes have had a ripple effect throughout the industry which has led some people to believe that only light retouching should be performed. Strangely, I now see this mentality bleeding into all genre’s.

How Far Is Too Far?

This is the center of the debate. The truth is, the answer is not as cut and dry as people may think, at least, not in my opinion. Retouching is just another stage of the photography process. It’s another skill that every photographer must learn, just like learning how to take a photo. If you leave it aside because you’ve been sucked into the #nofilter mentality, then you’re ignoring a whole world of possibilities for your art.

For me, I have no qualms with spending hours and hours retouching a photo. However, when it comes to portraits, I always want to maintain skin detail, never remove something permanent, and try to keep the use of tools like Liquify to a minimum. With my family photography, I NEVER heavily edit children or go near the Liquify tool. I shudder to think of the emotional damage it could cause a child to see themselves edited in a way that changed their appearance for the “better”. That said, if I have an adult who wants me to do a lot of Liquifying to change their appearance, which I’ve had, then I don’t mind doing it; so long as they pay for my time.

a before and after comparison of retouching a portrait

Morally, I think we’re all very aware of what retouchers can do now. It’s not my place to question the desires of my clients, so I have no issue completing the tasks they ask. On the other hand, the debate about the images of people we portray in magazines etc. is a whole other story. Personally, I’d love to see more accurate representations in magazines etc. but I understand why that’s not the case.

The strange thing is that this desire to only apply minimal edits seems to have stemmed from portrait photography but has seeped into all genre’s. If someone finds out that much of the image you have created was achieved in post, your credibility seems to drop. I don’t get that. Maybe it’s coming from those that lack skills as a retoucher and hence are quick to jump on the minimal editing bandwagon. Who knows?

[REWIND: 4 WAYS TO RETOUCH SKIN COLOR IN PHOTOSHOP WE SHOULD ALL KNOW]

Well, I’m here to say that there is nothing wrong with retouching. You’re going to have to find your own rules and boundaries, based on your personal feelings and your genre, but do not neglect retouching as a skill. It is just as important as learning how to use your camera, lighting, posing, and so on. Don’t get me wrong, an ability to “get it right in camera” is extremely useful but if you feel that “fixing it in post” would be quick, easier, or produce a better result, then don’t be afraid to do it. If you want to push your photos into completely new realms with the aid of Photoshop, then go for it. Don’t limit your art because of a misguided mentality.

Summary | How Can I Learn To Become A Good Retoucher?

Thankfully, there are so many good resources out there for learning Photoshop. Here’s a few that I would recommend:

Julia Kuzmenko Mckim – Master Dodge and Burn, Go Pro: Studio Beauty
Vibrant shot

Those are just a few which sprung to mind now, but there are loads of great resources out there. Having learned the skills, it’s all about practice, as it always is, and finding a way to refine your technique / discover your style.

If you’d like to read more articles like this, be sure to click FOLLOW on my profile, click here to do so.

Finally, if you’ve not discovered SLR Lounge Premium yet I encourage you to check it out. It’s an amazing service which includes some fantastic tutorials for both amateurs and professionals. You can find it here.

About

Max began his career within the film industry. He’s worked on everything from a banned horror film to multi-million-pound commercials crewed by top industry professionals. After suffering a back injury, Max left the film industry and is now using his knowledge to pursue a career within photography.

Website: SquareMountain 
Instagram: Follow Author

Q&A Discussions

Please or register to post a comment.

  1. Aliza Keya

    Retouching procedure is not the only camera focus. It is depending on photoshop. The designer has a creative idea and they use them on a there photo retouching system.When we see the image it looks different.and people cannot believe how is it possible.high n retouch completely changes an image. Some of the time it becomes odd or sometimes better.But I appreciate your thought.Thanks for sharing with us for your kind information.

    | |
  2. Lenzy Ruffin

    The only part of this I disagree with is “much of retouching’s bad reputation has come from a few, large-scale, mainstream media mistakes…” It’s not a few mistakes. The extreme, double-digit-hour photoshop edit is the rule, rather than the exception, in terms of what we are presented all day, every day.

    Do a Google images search of “O Magazine”, for example. I defy you to find a issue where they didn’t cut her weight by fifty pounds or more. I remember seeing one issue at the grocery store checkout a couple of years ago that looked like they put her face on a twelve-year-old girl’s body. And this is from someone whose brand is self-empowerment, love yourself, etc. The cover of every single issue is an example of extreme photoshop.

    I cited only one magazine, but this applies to everything the media delivers. The extreme, extreme, extreme photoshop edit is what they try to promote as real life and perhaps now people are more informed and tired of aspiring to false realities.

    I agree with your perspective on using photoshop responsibly. But I think the #nofilter thing comes from how rarely “responsible photoshopping” is reflected in the images presented by mass media. I will say that I think new photographers should work exclusively to get it right in-camera and not start learning the photoshop toolkit until they’ve gained some level of photography mastery.

    | |
  3. Ben Perrin

    I agree. Getting it right in camera is extremely important. However, that may mean exposing differently to the final result. Dani Diamond for example deliberately underexposes and then pushes the shadows in post. The key word is deliberately.

    As for retouching, I suppose that’s a matter of whether you view photography as art or true to life capture. Personally I want to create something, put my perspective on it. I laughed at that #nofilter comment. People don’t realise how much lighting and makeup make a difference.

    | |