Advertisement

Why I Love Photography, but Hate My Camera

Hate-My-Camera

Peta Pixel came out with a very interesting article on photography vs. the camera. Essentially, the author of the post, Steve Giralt, talks about how we as photographers can get stuck in the gear lust, arguing in the forums over how this is better than that, and vice versa. The age old Canon vs Nikon debate is essentially the Hatfields and McCoys of the camera world.

But the camera is just a tool, right? Steve’s argument is that despite the latest hoopla on the latest and greatest, it really is the photographer, not the camera, that can capture that special image. It reminds me of a quote I ran into which says:

A camera is like a guitar; it is just a box with a hole in the middle. It only makes noise until an artist picks it up and makes beautiful art.

So what Steve is trying to say that a “better” camera doesn’t automatically makes you a better photographer.

Be sure to read the rest of Steve’s article on Peta Pixel.

What do you guys think?


(By the way, I shoot my fashion and commercial almost exclusively with micro 4/3 camera, as you can see from my website, Fotosiamo.com)


Advertisement
  • http://www.facebook.com/juan.cespedes1 Juan Cespedes

    i think this is a load of bull. Painters don’t hate there brushes because it limits there finesse with getting the paint on to the canvas. This is a terrible excuses for blaming the tools.

    Its a shame this rant has gotten so much attention

  • http://twitter.com/ndkohlman Nathan Kohlman

    A better camera or lens or gadget does not make you a better photographer. It simply opens a new world of possibilities. It allows you to capture more detail, sharper details, less grain etc.. It allows you to shoot in lower light or difficult light. These upgrades just provide opportunities. A new camera or lens might allow you to capture more details in the shadows or highlights or both you could then possibly push your photoshop / lightroom skills to a new level. It might even speed up your work flow.

    A lot of pros will tell you it is not the gear that makes the photo it is the photographer and while this is generally true there are those times when it was the sharpness of a lens or dynamic range of an DSLR that makes all the difference. Its not like they would do a whole studio shoot or a wedding with a compact point and shoot. While they would nail the composition the camera is simply not capable of the results of an DSLR.

  • http://twitter.com/stevegiralt Steve Giralt

    Thanks again for sharing Joe!

  • http://www.facebook.com/ThePeyman Peyman Razavi

    I agree with this article, and is something I think about often. And as a musician too, I totally relate to the guitar reference and often make the same analogy myself. However I don’t think GAS is a bad thing.. new gear excites me and keeps me motivated to try new stuff. I just sold my 5D2 to get a 5D3. Is it gonna make me a better photographer? No. But it will give me bragging rights and make me think I’m a better photographer :p

  • http://www.danaseilhan.com Dana Seilhan

    tl;dr version: It’s the photographer, not the camera.

    And, well, that’s true probably 90 percent of the time. But there are times you need your camera to do certain things but those tasks exceed the camera’s technological limits. For example, I’ve taken some awesome shots with my Samsung digicam (hush, you), but I have to watch it in anything but bright daylight because my Samsung craps itself in dim light. It ain’t pretty. Also, even in manual mode it decides for me what its minimum and maximum f-stops will be. Maddening. Also, its recycle time after using the flash is way too slow, especially if I use redeye.

    I have a Canon 7D now, though I still use the Samsung in very casual situations where I don’t care about picture quality, because it’s not as clunky. Of course, now I run up against the learning curve. I have owned a Canon AT-1 for many years now and it’s fairly easy to take awesome pictures with it, but *this* one *thinks.* I’m also Very Not Enamored of everyone’s tendency now to over-rely on post-production. I feel like I am competing with Barbie, Ken, and the Plastic People in their artificial world with a giant fake plastic moon. Not a good feeling. So I just shoot first, ask questions later, consult the manual and try not to obsess too much.

  • http://www.facebook.com/james.busse James Busse

    I understand the want to have the newest latest greatest, and I have worked weddings in Vegas for more than a year, I have a pretty awesome portfolio put together of fashion, lingerie and weddings. But I am only 3 years into the industry and I’m using a Canon Rebel T1i. Most people scoff when they hear or see what I have to work with and I have been turned down for many jobs because my gear hasnt been upgraded yet. I say take a look at my images. Not my camera. Those who actually see my images have been quite happy to hire me for work.

  • Gilly Ribeiro

    As a guitarist and a photographer, I couldn’t agree more! :-)

Read previous post:
Lightroom-4-Mixology-SLR-Lounge-Portrait-Retouch
Retouching Portraits in Lightroom 4 – LR4 Tutorial and Mixology Episode

Retouching portraits is one of those areas where you can...

Close